Skip to content

Why Job Matching Matters More Than Job Titles

Issue #5

September 9, 2026

Why Accurate Job Matching Is the Foundation of Compensation Benchmarking

Compensation surveys are often described as collections of salary data. In practice, the quality of the analysis depends on something that happens before the numbers are reported: job matching.

A salary comparison is meaningful only when the underlying jobs are reasonably comparable. That sounds straightforward, but job titles can make the process deceptively difficult.

Why titles can mislead

Law firms develop titles based on history, culture, department structure and local practice. A Director of Finance at one firm may lead a national function with substantial staff and strategic authority. The same title at another firm may describe a more operational role with a narrower scope.

The reverse can also occur. An Accounting Manager at one firm may perform work comparable to an Assistant Director elsewhere. If compensation analysis relies on titles alone, the resulting comparison may be inaccurate.

Responsibilities provide the better foundation

Remington instructs participants to match firm jobs to survey benchmarks based on responsibilities. Generally, a role should reflect between 75% and 125% of the benchmark job’s responsibilities. The percentage match reported for each survey sample provides useful context about how closely participant roles align with the benchmark.

Most reported matches are at 100%, indicating a strong relationship between the participant’s job content and the survey definition.

The matching range allows practical flexibility. Very few real-world roles correspond word-for-word with a survey description. The objective is not perfect identity. It is a strong, defensible comparison based on the central purpose and level of the job.

Questions to consider when matching

A careful job match should look beyond task lists. Compensation professionals may consider:

  • The primary purpose of the position
  • The level of decision-making authority
  • Organizational and geographic scope
  • Reporting relationships
  • Staff and budget responsibility
  • Required experience and expertise
  • The balance of strategic and operational work

These factors help determine whether two jobs are truly comparable.

Avoiding common matching errors

One common mistake is title matching: selecting the benchmark with the closest title without reviewing the description.

Another is incumbent matching: choosing a benchmark based on the individual employee’s background or salary rather than the job itself. The role should be matched according to its responsibilities, not the characteristics of the current incumbent.

A third challenge arises when an employee wears more than one hat. In those cases, one benchmark may not fully reflect the position. Remington’s methodology recommends blending data from two or more survey jobs when responsibilities are meaningfully divided among distinct functions.

Why the match affects the decision

Poor matching can lead to false conclusions about whether an employee is paid competitively. It may also distort internal comparisons, salary ranges and recruiting decisions.

A strong match does not automatically determine the correct salary. Compensation philosophy, internal equity, performance, experience and other factors still matter. But accurate matching gives the organization a sound external reference point.

The value of detailed job descriptions

Detailed benchmark descriptions are therefore not secondary documentation. They are a central part of a credible survey.

For participants, descriptions improve the consistency of submissions. For survey users, they make the resulting data more useful and defensible. For the market as a whole, they help ensure that reported compensation reflects comparable work.

Better questions produce better comparisons

The most useful question is not, “Which survey title looks like our title?” It is, “Which benchmark best reflects the purpose, scope and responsibilities of this job?”

That shift from title to content is one of the foundations of professional compensation analysis. The better the match, the more meaningful the market information becomes.

Other Articles in this Series